The careerist: ‘There’s a human need to show how good we are’
By Rhymer Rigby
Published: The Financial Times, March 1 2010 02:00 | Last updated: March 1 2010 02:00
The annual awards season culminates with this Sunday’s Oscars, but it is not just the film industry that likes to recognise its own. So how can you boost your career with a gong in your own industry?
Do awards really make you stand out? “They differentiate you from other people and act as a kind of third-party endorsement, which is very valuable in today’s tough jobs market,” says Catherine Kaputa, a New York-based personal branding expert. “People like things that are easy to latch on to and remember, so they’ll say: ‘Oh, he or she won an award for that.’ It can become a kind of recommendation.”
Alan Young, creative director at St Luke’s, the London advertising agency, adds: “In creative circles, there’s a huge desire for peer group recognition and having produced award-winning work will certainly keep you employable and may boost your earning power.”
Are all awards equal? No. For a start, awards are much more important and prevalent in some sectors than others. Second, the money-making potential for the people behind the awards (usually via pricey ceremonies and high entry fees) means there are plenty of less credible schemes out there. So you need to do your research.
“There are awards that aren’t worth the paper they’re written on and to be encouraged by them is a road to confusion,” warns Ben Williams, a business psychologist in Edinburgh. Indeed, having a low-rent award might even tarnish your personal brand.
Should I advertise my awards? “You need to weave it into your personal narrative rather than shout about it,” says Ms Kaputa. “You don’t want to seem arrogant. If a third party brings it up, that’s great.”
Equally, you should not campaign too hard to be entered for awards. It is fine to promote yourself, but do not appear to be overly self-promoting or, worse, deluded. Stevan Rolls, human resources director of the professional services firm Deloitte, says that for those who win them, an award is usually just the icing on the cake: “The important thing to remember is that . . . they tend to be good anyway – that’s what really drives their career progression.”
Are there other benefits? Whether or not you win, awards can still be a powerful incentive to raise your game. “Being in the running for an award can give you a goal to work towards and act as motivator,” says Ms Kaputa. “There’s a human need to show how good we are, particularly if we’re ambitious.”
Awards can also have wider implications for the organisation as a whole. “When an individual or a team wins an award, it says something about us as a firm,” says Mr Rolls. “Everyone feels good.”
Mr Williams says they can also help put training and development on the agenda.
Are there any pitfalls to watch out for? “If you become too fixated on them and don’t win, you can be crushed,” says Mr Young. He adds that too narrow a focus on sectoral prizes can be harmful in other ways, too. “In our industry, the ads that win awards are often the crazy, weird showy things that slip through the net. Having an award-winning agenda can often create a lot of tension with the clients you’re working with.”


